Stigmata

What a dumb movie. A Pittsburg atheist starts getting these crucifixion wounds which, historically, have only been experienced by very religious people, like St. Francis of Assisi. You're wondering for what mystical reason the stimata have chosen to afflict this non-religious person.

The answer? It's not a mystical selection at all, but a regular old possession. A stigmatic priest dies and on that same day occupies the body of the atheist woman. They even find out his name: Father Almeida, from Rio. If this is the story they're hustling, why did they even throw in that stigmata angle? Right, because of all the soul's characteristics that are going manifest during a possession, the ultra-rare stigmata is the one that this dead guy passes on.